Character Development in Youth Sports: Examining Infractions
and Intervention Strategies in a Competitive Tournament

Introduction. Findings about whether sport promotes character are mixed, in part, because character is often not an intentional part of sport programming. Promoting character in sport requires holistic approaches that address myriad facets of the sport environment. Our objective was to examine variation in character infractions during a competitive youth multi-sport (soccer, basketball, volleyball) tournament in Mexico. Identifying sources of poor character may help practitioners identify intervention points. The tournament included two top awards, one for performance, and the other for character. The character award was administered through the Fair Play Initiative, in which youth athletes learned about the character virtues that were central to the tournament (e.g., joy, gratitude, respect, fraternity, and honesty). This study uses innovative data capturing character from multiple sources (athletes, coaches, spectators). Findings advance previous research that tends to focus on one source of character and that typically do not include information about spectators.

Method and Results. Sixty eight teams from 11 school districts played 774 games. Trained observers rated games marking character infractions (0=no, 1=yes) on a 9-cell matrix categorizing sources (players, coaches, spectators) by targets (officials, own team, opposing team). Frequency analyses suggested that spectators exhibited infractions more often (11.0%) than players (7.9%) and coaches (7.0%). Officials and opposing teams were targeted more often (11.5% and 11.7%, respectively) than one’s own team (3.6%). Infractions were likely to occur from multiple sources within schools (χ²(1) = 112.83–154.77, ps < .001, phis = .27-.32, ASRs > 10.6) rather than singular sources across schools.

Discussion. Theory suggests that treating sport as a “game” without real world consequences is one reason character infractions occur. Thus, character interventions are needed in youth sport. This study provides one example of how youth sport tournaments might encourage stakeholders to take the character aspects of sport seriously. Although many character interventions utilize strengths-based approaches, reducing deficits should also be included. Our findings align with previous research highlighting the importance of whole-school strategies that integrate multiple sources, instead of targeting one source. Addressing character collectively, and also holding spectators accountable, may be the most effective approach to fostering character development in youth sport.